India Rises, Leaving Poor Behind

Dr. Jonathan Fine

fine

Dr. Jonathan Fine, speaking to UW students

Unlike in China, the rising economic tide in India is not floating many boats, to lift the poor up and out of poverty.

India’s rich and middle-class sectors are riding higher, getting richer, says Dr. Jonathan Fine, founder of the Nobel Peace Prize-winning group Physicians for Human Rights, while India’s hundreds of millions of poor people remain firmly anchored to the bottom.

“Things are actually getting worse in many of India’s rural villages,” Fine said on a recent visit to Seattle. The Boston physician spoke in early June to a student-run global health group at the UW. Fine was in Seattle to meet with — and recruit volunteers for — a local branch of an organization devoted to assisting India’s poor, Association for India’s Development.

Malnutrition rates tell the story of inequity in India, Fine said. Hundreds of millions of Indians continue to live on semi-starvation diets, he said, despite there being enough food in India to feed everyone and despite India’s overall economic progress.

RELATED  Nepal court orders rapid compensation and care for acid attack victims

According to UNICEF, China has reduced its rate of child malnutrition to 7 percent while in India today more than 40 percent of young children are malnourished – a rate worse than in many sub-Saharan African countries.

“Initiatives aimed at improving health and welfare won’t have much effect if malnutrition is not dealt with first,” Fine contended. Hungry people are more prone to illness, he said, and malnourished children don’t learn or develop properly. “The Indian government continues to largely neglect this massive problem.”

Undernourished in India

Mike Urban / Seattle Post-Intelligencer

Nearly half of India’s children are malnourished.

Tapoja Chaudhuri, who teaches at the UW’s South Asia Center, and her soon-to-be-doctor husband Sunil Aggarwal (he gets his MD in a week), agreed with Fine’s comments and are, for the same reasons, planning to become more active in efforts to assist India’s poor. Both said the gap between rich and poor in India is growing.

RELATED  Despite slowdown, India could achieve double-digit growth with more jobs for women

Chaudhuri, who grew up in Calcutta, said there are terrible conflicts raging across many parts of India today due to these entrenched inequities. Though the government portrays the fight as against communist terrorists, Chaudhuri said the conflicts are fueled not so much by ideology but by the disenfranchisement of many poor communities. Government economic policies, she said, tend to focus on large-scale development projects rather than on anything that directly benefits the rural poor.

“It is not at all paradoxical to me that India’s rapid economic growth is accompanied by high rates of malnutrition,” Chaudhuri said. The way India is achieving its overall growth, she said, is by often bulldozing over – figuratively and literally — already impoverished communities.

Chaudhuri plans to work on social justice issues in India next fall while Aggarwal, who plans to someday go there as a doctor, completes his residency at Virginia Mason Medical Center.

(Originally published on my blog.)

Share.

About Author

Tom Paulson

Tom Paulson is founder and lead journalist at Humanosphere. Prior to operating this online news site, he reported on science,  medicine, health policy, aid and development for the Seattle Post-Intelligencer. Contact him at tom[at]humanosphere.org or follow him on Twitter @tompaulson.