That’s the gist of a new report by Global Post, which says the links between local rebel movements in Mali, Nigeria and Somalia and the Islamist terror group Al Qaeda are growing stronger. The report coincides with today’s anniversary of the terrorist attacks of 9-11.
It’s a good series, but I can’t help but worry that this angle will translate into a simplistic pitch for a military response to the continent’s troubles with various separatist movements. Are these conflicts really about Al Qaeda? I’m not so sure.
Here’s an artsy map accompanying the GP’s series on this thesis:
Some of these alleged linkages to Al Qaeda are not new, of course, and most are often preceded by squishy lingo such as “believed to be” linked with or “has ties to” the terror group.
It’s often not clear just how strong such ties are, or even if they mean much more than sharing a similar ideology or antipathy. Nigeria’s Boko Haram, for example, is perhaps best thought of as an Islamist separatist movement that has only recently sought to ally itself with Al Qaeda. Does that translate into anything on a material basis, or is it just a boast aimed at boosting the group’s terrorizing image?
Somalia’s Al Shabaab clearly considers itself part of Al Qaeda. But militant movements in parts of Africa and hostility to the U.S. goes way back (remember Blackhawk Down?) and it would be simplistic to think this is all due to Al Qaeda’s influence.
In any case, the possibility of a growing Al Qaeda movement in Africa should be taken seriously. Bin Laden had his base in Sudan for many years in the early 1990s. The question is how best to respond to this trend. Will we take the standard route and support a policy of responding to terror simply with military or police actions? Or will we also battle for hearts and minds?
Gen. Carter F. Ham, head of the U.S. Africa Command, aka AfriCom, had this to say today:
To successfully defeat terrorism requires not only the collective efforts of many nations, but it requires the combined effects of military, diplomatic, development, economic, good governance, education, food security – it requires all of those to work in concert to address the underlying causes that establish the conditions in which young people, primarily young men, find themselves attracted to these terrorist organizations.
Sounds good, but AfriCom (which was launched by Donald Rumsfeld during the Bush Administration) has yet to actually find a home anywhere in Africa. It was supposed to be headquartered somewhere on the continent in 2008 but has so far remained in Stuttgart, Germany.
Africans, and others, appear reluctant to allow the U.S. military to establish a large presence there. And a new survey indicates many Americans are also not that interested in expanding our military footprint overseas.
If Al Qaeda is indeed gaining turf in parts of Africa, the first step is make sure we understand why. Are these separatist groups joining forces with Al Qaeda for ideological or practical reasons? Was Ho Chi Minh primarily a communist or a Vietnam nationalist? Many would say the failure to answer this question accurately prompted what was, until Afghanistan, our longest war.
Al Qaeda is probably best thought of as a fungus rather than as a military force. It tends to only really flourish in places of rot – places of poverty, injustice and dysfunction.
Sure, it’s a lot more fun and entertaining to use a flame-thrower to fight a fungus. But the more reasonable approach is to just stop the rot.
As an excuse to post this video poking fun at North Korea’s Supreme Leader, I ask: Is humor more powerful than diplomacy, politics or popular outrage? Read More
- John Oliver explains how the US contributed to Uganda's anti-gay law
- Meet the world's 'goodest' country: Ireland
Ding Haitao/XinHua/Xinhua Press/Corbis The Chinese government released its second-ever white paper, outlining its foreign assistance from 2010-2012. As the country continues to make itself an international development player, the new details about how it spent is money gives a better … Read More
- Documentary questions motives for Westerners 'helping' Africa
- A peaceful and food-secure Africa is not just a dream
Captive aid worker Warren Weinstein before and after he was kidnapped in Pakistan. AP Warren Weinstein had been in Pakistan for some seven years, working with a contractor on local-scale economic development. Then four days before he was due to … Read More
- Visiting al Shabaab – How terrorizing terrorists creates more terror
- Al Qaeda 2.0 - Boko Haram, Al Shabaab and Extremism in Africa
A Syrian refugee woman completing her shopping in Amman, Jordan, using food vouchers provided by WFP. DfID The international organizations that are the first to act when disaster strikes were called out last week by the UK branch of Doctors … Read More
- What does China's white paper tell us about its foreign aid spending?
- Global crises cause humanitarian spending to spike
Thai protesters raise three fingers while protesting during an anti-coup demonstration inside shopping mall in downtown Bangkok to denounce the country’s May 22 coup. AP Photo/Sakchai Lalit The Thai military, who recently took control of the country, announced the ban … Read More
- Containing global violence costs nearly $10 trillion a year
- Philippines Response Turning the Corner, says US Official
Boko Haram spokesperson Abubakar Shekau, speaking in the group’s new video. In a new video, Nigerian Islamist group Boko Haram demands for the exchange of prisoners for the more than 200 schoolgirls currently held captive by the group in north … Read More
- Today's bombing news
- After 9/11: How the global humanitarian agenda was changed, or not